12
February
2012

Spring orientation

Both state government officials and University administrators should be candid when dealing with partisan issues in higher education

By on March 16, 2010

Though he did not get a Spring Break, state Attorney General and University alumnus Ken Cuccinelli certainly caught some heat last week for a letter he issued advising Virginia public colleges and universities to strip references to sexual orientation from their nondiscrimination polices. “Virginia’s public universities are, at all times, subject to the control of the General Assembly,” Cuccinelli wrote. “The General Assembly has on numerous occasions considered and rejected creating a protected class denied by ‘sexual orientation.’” Encouraging that no state university “reaches beyond the boundaries established,” he made waves that caught everyone’s attention.

The Virginia attorney general’s main function is to provide legal expertise to state government entities, including public colleges. By issuing this controversial warning to colleges, Cuccinelli clearly blurred the line between his professional duties and his political agenda. Although The Cavalier Daily are not trained lawyers and would be remiss to speculate about the legal substance of the letter, this action underscores Cuccinelli’s strong social conservative laurels. It also perhaps demonstrates his intent to push partisan political issues into the attorney general’s office.

At first, the letter put Virginia colleges in a precarious position, caught between upholding the ideal that “all men is created equal” and faithfully abiding by state law. A number of students across the state mobilized to protest Cuccinelli’s letter. The University’s Queer & Allied Activism group called on students to barrage the attorney general’s Twitter and Facebook page. More than 1,000 students at Virginia Commonwealth University rallied to express their opposition to Cuccinelli’s stance.

The contentious nature of the letter brought Gov. Bob McDonnell into the mix — possibly for damage control. McDonnell, however, has supported similar positions in the past; he issued an executive order just last month barring discrimination in the state workforce on grounds that include race, sex, religion and age, but not sexual orientation. But in a move to clear up confusion among state college administrators and students, McDonnell has intervened appropriately.

“We will not tolerate discrimination based on sexual orientation or any other basis that’s outlawed under state or federal law or the Constitution,” McDonnell told reporters last Wednesday. He took a clear-cut stance, slightly at odds with both his executive order last month and Cuccinelli’s letter, by issuing an executive directive condemning the discrimination of state employees on the basis of sexual orientation. McDonnell cited the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, making a direct appeal to the U.S. Constitution.

President John T. Casteen, III was quick to respond. In an e-mail to all University students, Casteen expressed his personal gratitude to the governor and called the directive a “combination of wisdom and bravery.” The e-mail implied that Casteen initially was alarmed at the attorney general’s letter and could not have been more pleased with the governor’s response. Given the amount of press Cuccinelli’s letter received and because of its controversial nature, Casteen’s candidness with addressing the University community is welcome. University administrators should not shy away from communicating openly with students whenever hot-button issues like this arise in the future.

As the discussion continues, we hope both the governor’s office and the General Assembly will not ignore how strongly students and University administrators feel about this issue. Though the directive appears to be relatively straightforward, students only can hope that it will turn out to be, as Del. Robert Marshall, R-Prince William, said, more than a “press release with fluff.”

2 Responses to “Spring orientation”

  1. David Neal says:

    The following is the text of the letter that I wrote to Teresa Sullivan, new President of the University of Virginia, with a copy to each member of the Board of Visitors:

    As an alumnus (Col ’74) and a long-time supporter of the University of Virginia, I was dismayed to learn of Virginia Attorney General Cuccinelli’s letter to Virginia’s state colleges and universities instructing them to rescind their policies prohibiting discrimination against gays and lesbians. I would be even more dismayed to learn that the University of Virginia has acquiesced in this bigoted attempt to turn back the clock.

    I am nearly sixty years old. I grew up in Charlotte County, Virginia and I remember the time when discrimination was institutionalized against another marginalized minority. Even as a child in the fifties and sixties, I knew that the disparity and discrimination that I witnessed all around me daily was wrong. Yet, Virginia’s leaders used the most pernicious and insidious reasoning to maintain a series of laws that corrupted the commonwealth. It was shameful then and Mr. Cuccinelli’s letter is shameful now, as other states and communities work to expand the umbrella of civil rights guaranteed to all of us by our Federal and State constitutions.

    I sincerely hope that my alma mater—my University of Virginia—declines to be a part of this new disgraceful episode in Virginia’s history. I know that many of my fellow alumni and alumna join me in this cause.

    Report this comment

    Agree/Disagree: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

  2. Sean says:

    You can say one thing about Bob Marshall, he doesn’t mince his words or play nice with the bad guys..

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6k4RrKNk7s&NR=1

    In that one minute, he did his best to protect the health and welfare of Virginia’s college students. But the John Casteen’s of the world won the day in the end. There have been countless women at UVA since then who have had their health permanently damaged by this garbage as a result.

    In stark contrast to these endless, ad nauseum debates over discrimination against gays (where?), these are the stories of vomiting, bleeding, crying, depression, and death that Mr. Casteen and the folks at the Teen Center know will be kept quiet and out of the headlines.

    http://www.realoptionsforwomen.com/MorningAfterPill.aspx

    Here’s hoping that Bob and our new governor can take up the battle for women and children’s health once more, and return medical ethics to Virginia’s colleges and universities. The bad guys have caused way too much damage and misery already.

    Report this comment

    Agree/Disagree: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0