New secret society, The Ten, seeks to reclaim elitism

E-mail reveals new organization to selection of student leaders, administrators across Grounds


A new organization that claims to be a secret society has emerged on Grounds, touting its mission "to protect student self-governance, to reignite students' absent strength of spirit and to chide the insufficient and debauched elements." Known as The Ten, the society's members "wish to differentiate [themselves] and to also create a culture of elitism," according to an e-mail sent to The Cavalier Daily by an anonymous member of the group.

"The Ten want only the best," the e-mail stated. "The most creative. The most proactive. The most enthusiastic. We want everyone who isn't a tool, fratstar, sorostitute or wishy-washy rich kid. The Ten is a meritocracy - and The Ten strongly believe some University leaders are just not worth our time, whereas others clearly are."

The Ten differentiates itself from other secret societies on Grounds by its open application process for membership, which will last until March 10, according to the group's Web site,

The Ten hopes to accept members who will improve the state of elitism at the University, according to the e-mail and Web site.

"Elitism on Grounds isn't practiced rightly," the anonymous society member stated. "There's a difference between the elitism that guides the Honor Committee and various fraternities on Grounds and the elitism that guided the true, honorable gentleman of the past. We believe the best should carry themselves as the best - but that if the weak and childish carry themselves as the best, something is wrong. It's not arrogance - it's elitism practiced rightly, when the best are honored and adored, and competition breeds better and better members of society."

To reveal these intentions to the University community, The Ten introduced itself via e-mail to leaders such as Dean of Students Allen Groves, University Judiciary Chair Michael Chapman, Student Council College representative Eugene Resnick and JJ Litchford, the Honor Committee's vice chair for community relations. The society followed the first e-mail with another one that claimed The Ten knew how many times those leaders opened the first e-mail - or if they deleted it altogether.

Chapman and Resnick said The Ten's account of their e-mail activity is, in fact, accurate.

Resnick - of whom The Ten spoke positively because he opened the initial e-mail four times - said he was "very disturbed" by the society's tracking capabilities. Nevertheless, he said he remains skeptical about the organization's legitimacy.

"They said, 'Your interest will not be forgotten,'" Resnick said. "I thought it was OK that Dean Groves and my name were in the same sentence but I don't know whether this is an actual organization or a farce."

Chapman, on the other hand, was scolded by The Ten because he deleted the first e-mail and unsubscribed from future messages from the society. Chapman said this message felt like an intrusion of privacy but said he is fine with at least one aspect of this public disclosure.

"If they want to show to all those people that I don't believe in their ideals, that's fine with me," Chapman said.

The Ten, however, specified  that the e-mail was nothing but humorous.

"Honestly, please don't take such preliminary remarks to be anything but a bit of attempted (but sorely lacking) comedy," a society member stated. "The real reason THE TEN are reaching out again, of course, is to emphasize that we are a very real and very serious society of like-minded brothers and to emphasize that we are very real and very serious about receiving applications."

Though the group may take itself seriously, second-year Architecture student Jamie Dean questioned the group's ideals, as it thus far does not seem to live up to her idea that University secret societies are supposed to give back to the community. Moreover, she added that she does not think the organization is fulfilling its own goals.

"I think the fact that you're chosen to be in [The Ten] doesn't make it elitist," she said.

Chapman added that he is unsure of the organization's future.

"It either could go very positively or it could end up very negatively," he said. "I guess it depends on whether the group amounts to anything or not."

-Bethel Habte contributed to this article.

Published February 15, 2010 in News

The Cavalier Daily welcomes thoughtful, respectful and relevant comments that contribute to a public dialogue. In order to maintain a high level of discourse, all comments must be approved by our moderator. For more information, view our full comment policy.


Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed

Tradd St. Croix
(02/15/10 9:26am)

Catchy name - always nice to meet fellow Pat Conroy fans.

Having read the book I think we all know how this ends.

Will McLean
(02/15/10 1:54pm)

A little context for those who haven't enjoyed reading the Lords of Discipline...

(02/15/10 3:42pm)

Secret Societies have and always will be the antithesis of any true democracy, especially Jefferson's democracy. JFK explains it best: Secrecy is Repugnant (1961 Speech).

(02/15/10 4:37pm)

If this isn't a joke, I don't know what is.

Tally Ho
(02/15/10 4:51pm)

This is the stupidest thing I've ever seen.

My guess is that someone on the Cav Daily exec board is one of the people behind this; why else would such a lame "secret society" receive this depth of reporting?

E. Arvidson
(02/15/10 6:36pm)

Sounds to me like you've been trolled.

For one, "the society’s tracking capabilities" are technologically impossible.

Way to fact check and way to report on an organization that as mentioned, will likely not amount to anything.

Will McLean
(02/15/10 8:38pm)
Comment .... from the looks if it these gentlemen (women?) reside in the steam tunnels near the amphitheater... or at least that is their mailing address.

(02/15/10 10:18pm)

Wow, this group is so elite that you have to read hebrew to understand what their laws mean. Looks to me like AEPi had nothing else to do since nationals revoked their charter, so they decided to start a club.

(02/15/10 10:45pm)

“Elitism on Grounds isn’t practiced rightly,” the anonymous society member stated. “There’s a difference between the elitism that guides the Honor Committee and various fraternities on Grounds and the elitism that guided the true, honorable gentleman of the past. We believe the best should carry themselves as the best — but that if the weak and childish carry themselves as the best, something is wrong. It’s not arrogance — it’s elitism practiced rightly, when the best are honored and adored, and competition breeds better and better members of society.”

Who exactly determines who is "true" and "honorable", who is "weak" and "childish", and who may rightfully "carry themselves as the best"? Oh, of course, the "elite", because after all... they are the "elite."

Completely tautological argument for why this secret society should exist.

James Worthy
(02/16/10 3:26am)

Can we as a student body chill the fuck out? Stop killing fun. Stop taking yourselves seriously. If you kill the fun this place turns into William and Mary and they have a high suicide rate for a reason. This little Aspergers-Ego-Club is a symptom of the overall safe and sober culture that's ruining everything. None of us are special and most of you aren't interesting. Get over it. We have four years to be reckless psychotics - to get twisted, torn, frayed and laid. You learn by fucking up. If you can't do that three nights a week and hold down a decent average just quit. Never missed a class? 4.0? Do you have any good stories? Didn't think so. You've got the next fifty years to rot in your fluorescent coffin, max out your credit cards to buy stupid shit, and put your ugly kids through college. Keep things in perspective.

Tens- I know you're reading this, you egomaniacs. "We are here on Earth to fart around. Don't let anybody tell you any different"

Check it!
(02/16/10 3:37pm)

HAHAHAH. For some reason I feel like Zev Lebowitz is behind it. Either way, it's hilarious BS... like most secret societies @ U.Va.

[little john] yeaaaa
(02/17/10 2:27am)

ummm... haven't I seen this movie??

oh wait yea I have... original. oh and wordpress... nice. a blogging site.

I'm no expert, but since when do "secret" societies have open websites and accept applications..?

Barbara Pierson
(02/17/10 8:02pm)

I have to point out a little problem with James Worthy's comment, "You learn by fucking up". Apparently he is not educated about the Honor Code. You see, if you screw up on citations like Allison Routman, it is not an opportunity to learn rather an opportunity to throw you off the boat.

to Barbara Pierson
(02/17/10 8:31pm)

You have previously been very constructive in your comments and presentations to the honor committee, but when you start commenting on random Cav Daily articles that have no relevance to your cause it makes you look like a bit of a crazy person/blinded zealot.

(02/23/10 2:06pm)


(02/24/10 7:32am)

Nicely put, james and ricky. I don't know who to agree with, you all have valid points. I guess it would be james, cause everyone can just be chill.

To address the creepy tracking aspect, this is not "impossible" and in fact is a very simple trick. If there is an image in the email then when the email loads it will pull the image from the host website and this activity can be tracked. That's why outlook blocks images the first time in emails - so spammers won't be able to trace your computer.

Powered by powered by SNworks Solutions by The State News