An open letter to Dean Groves
A student’s letter to Dean Groves condemning an incident of bigotry
DEAN GROVES,
I really should be working on my thesis at the moment, but I am absolutely furious as a result of two cowards who just perpetrated what is the second unmistakably anti-Semitic affront against me in 24 hours. Earlier tonight, two young men stole the Israeli flag that I had displayed on the door of my own Room 7 West Lawn. From my desk, I heard something happening immediately outside my room and opened my door to find the two individuals fleeing, the door left missing a cherished and significant piece of personal property. This follows less than 24 hours after another incident in which someone wrote prominently on my dry-erase board "F--- Jews." And one month since the Zeta Psi episode.
The [alleged] Zeta Psi hazing event garnered publicity as a result of the young man being hospitalized, which of course is awful. It went unrecognized, however, that the [alleged] hazing involved feeding pledges dog food in addition to traditional Jewish foods, Matzo balls and Gefilte fish. This juxtaposition is no coincidence, and it is another unacceptable statement of anti-Semitism by a long-standing institution at our university. When I first heard about this, I was conflicted as to whether I should heed the request of some of my peers and notify the administration. Given this recent rise in blatant discrimination against Jews, I am now compelled to.
Despite the insistence of many, anti-Semitism is not a relic of the past. Of this I am sure. Yet, to find it expressed so unabashedly at the University founded by Thomas Jefferson, author of the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, is simply appalling. In my four years here, I have never felt as threatened as I do now. I am ashamed to admit that the thought crossed my mind of taking down the mezuzah that adorns my doorpost. I will not. I will not stop wearing my yarmulke or my tzitzit. I will not stop walking to services on the Sabbath. In the face of injury and offense, the Jewish response is to bring light into the world, to react with positivity.
Furthermore, as a resident of the Lawn, living in a room endowed by one of the University's premier student organizations, I am a proud representative of the communities and institutions of which I am a part. I have the opportunity and privilege to serve as a voice for my community. No longer will I hesitate for even a moment to express the concerns of my fellow Jews. As such, I will not allow this trend of anti-Semitism to go ignored. This is not something that the University, which I love so dearly, can leave unaddressed. We must respond, and respond constructively.
On April 13, at 5:30 p.m, I will be the closing speaker at the Interfaith Vigil of Blessing to celebrate the inauguration of our new president, Teresa A. Sullivan. I will be reciting for President Sullivan and our university a blessing that God lift His countenance and grant peace, [from] the oldest Biblical text that has been found, dating back over 2600 years. I sincerely wish that my invocation - that this entire vigil - not be in vain. I hope and expect that the student body, faculty and administration will use this event as an opportunity to express solidarity with all faiths, especially in response to this recent series of expressions to the contrary. I implore you and the rest of the University community to join me in promoting light over darkness, respect over bigotry, love over hate.
Dean Groves, this Vigil is a wonderful first step that I hope we all take advantage of - and I really do not mean to overly politicize the event, if that is how my idea is coming across - but I turn to you as a representative of our university: What else can be done to ensure that such disrespect is not taken lightly, that it receives due consideration?
Thank you very much,\nKeenan Davis
Keenan Davis is a fourth-year College student.
RSS


Commentary
Add your $0.02, go to the comment form or follow the comment feed
christian
(03/28/11 7:45am)Report
Bravo for an honest and needed letter. If we are to be the future leaders of this country, we need the courage and conscience to stand up and speak out. The reputation of this university is at stake.
Andrea
(03/29/11 1:43am)Report
I am glad that you had the courage to stand up for yourself and what you believe. And I hope that these people of Zeta Psi realize that the nature of their actions was blatantly discriminatory and unacceptable and, honestly, I hope they get punished for this....
Susanne
(03/29/11 9:41pm)Report
Thank you Keenan for finally saying something. While I'm not the most active in Hillel or other Jewish student groups on campus, I'm a Jewish student at this university, and I'm very proud of you for speaking up. You're courageous words are exactly what's needed.
Susanne
(03/29/11 9:42pm)Report
Thank you Keenan for finally saying something. While I'm not the most active in Hillel or other Jewish student groups on grounds, I'm a Jewish student at this university, and I'm very proud of you for speaking up. You're courageous words are exactly what's needed.
natalie
(03/30/11 5:58pm)Report
ask yourself what are we jews doing on campus that isnt compatible with the american christian values on campus. that would be logical no? an israeli flag?? when christian students are fighting forpalestinian freedom and justice?? you have to respect american values when you are a minority.
natalie
(03/30/11 6:02pm)Report
hillel=talmud racism. do you protest when israel passeslaws banning crosses and depictions of christ?
paulson
(03/30/11 6:12pm)Report
Maybe we should let you build a synagogue and holocaust memorial on campus too.
wahoo
(03/30/11 7:48pm)Report
I think several of the previous comments are absolutely disgusting and disturbing. It goes to show that anti-Semitism is still around. How horrible.
With that said, kudos for standing up for yourself and your community and just know that you have many allies at this University who are standing with you.
M
(03/31/11 11:51am)Report
Natalie.. not sure why you think support of Israel is in American minority idea... just look at the latest Gallup Poll done on the subject: \nhttp://www.gallup.com/poll/146408/americans-maintain-broad-support-israel.aspx
And as an American Christian, and an alum of UVA, I stand with Keenan.
americafirst
(03/31/11 1:30pm)Report
bbc poll.....last week..........64% of americans think israel is a liability to america. 2 days ago haaretz poll.......59% of american hispanics believe america should not support israel. 79% of british believe israel is an apartheid state. google "jews attack and spit on american christians visiting israel" google "jews burning new testaments in israel" the boguspoll you cite was commisioned by the adl and as usual uses "push polling"techgniques to skew reality and give the impression that their is broad support for that third world toilet of anti christian/muslim hate.only our elected representatives who are FORCED by aipac through intimidation support israel,no christian supports killing palestinian children and pregnant woman and christ haters.btw you are christian like my name is moishe lol.
M
(03/31/11 1:58pm)Report
Don't think for a minute you know anything about my belief systems or my faith. There are millions of Christians that stand with Israel - see Christians United for Israel for one small example. \nAnd funny you mention the killing of children and women.. the first thing that came to mind was the brutal, sadistic murder of the Fogels just a few weeks ago.
Holly
(04/01/11 5:45am)Report
I am a very proud Wahoo, CLAS 2002. I am also a very proud Jew living in Israel with my husband, and fellow Wahoo, and our 3 children. Thank you for your letter, Keenan. I'm very sorry to hear of these events happening at our university. We support you! I hope that many, many Wahoos now on campus have the courage to show you their support as well.
Sam
(04/01/11 3:28pm)Report
Know that many students and faculty at UVA support you and the Jewish community, Keenan. This kind of bigotry will not and should not be tolerated.
real deal
(04/02/11 12:54am)Report
brother, it's good that you wrote an intelligent letter. but my question is, where is your anger? why don't you insist that the university investigate? why aren't lawyers being called for hate-crimes against you? stolen propety, vandalism? why don't you speak out against anti-semitism on campus before you read the jewish prayer?! i remember anti-semitism at a college i attended. i do not love that place at all. it was ucla. the late 70s. huge swastika=magen david on a building. wasn't removed for a while. wasp frat guys saying jew-hate. zeta psi is a gross example of jewish assimliation to 'greek' culture. i urge you to continue to stand up for your people and seek justice. when people say "this kind of bigotry will not be tolerated" then ask them what the hell their going to do about it? you and your fellow jewish students, community and others do something. send a message that this won't be tolerated. and if they come by your room again, start chasing those slime and beat the crap out of them.
real deal
(04/02/11 12:58am)Report
i have to repeat: any people who 'kindly' say to you they're sorry and that this hate won't be tolerated...they must be challenged! what are you going to DO? send a message to the slime. they will not be tolerated. expulsion for those who stole your flag and vandalized your door with hate. zero tolerance for hate. period. if some slime shouts something about the fakestinians, slam 'em. verbal abuse, you felt threatened and defended yourself. let the slime know, very clearly, that their hate will not be tolerated for one minute.
volleyball
(04/02/11 1:48am)Report
in 1981 if you were to display a south african flag on your door I'm sure all the students would also look at you this way,what it says to all the non jewish students is "screw your values" im jewish and support anything my country does.If the south aficans had an organization like hillel on every college campus for the purpose of shilling for apartheid and invited apartheid regime soldiers and officials to attempt to lie and manipulate american student opinion the students would be resentful and rightfully so don't you agree? and the notion that other jewish students would post comments advising the student to call lawyers,file federal hate crime charges against the university ect is amazing.
christwasawaywardJew
(04/03/11 6:48pm)Report
Let's start with the basics. Yeshua Ben Joseph (aka jesus) was a Jew (if he even existed). The cult of christianity is just Judaism without the hard parts. Let's be frank here: christianity is a cheap copy of Judaism, which is why I find it so utterly hysterical that you pseudo christians berate and attack your Jewish fathers; you know, the forebears without which your pseudo Jud(e)o cult couldn't exist without.
Now let's move on to the fakestinian thing. Firstly, palestine is a Roman insult (not even an arabic word- no 'p' in arabic). It is derived from Philistine, who were seafaring greeks from the Aegean coast, not immigrant terrorist arabs trying to steal yet another Jewish land. Romans renamed the area as such because Jews rebelled against them. The modern concept of "Fakestine" holds about as much ground as unicorns and leprechauns, quite literally. How is it that these self-imposed "refugee" arabs have a nationality before they have a nation? Did you know that a fakestinian is considered a refugee until the end of time? Even if hundreds of generations have been born in another country, they're still deemed "refugees."
The only apartheid in the middle east is in every single theocratic, racist, illegal, 3rd world, terrorist hub, cesspool, arab and muslim country. Muslim slavery STILL exists TO THIS DAY in SUDAN. I doubt I'll hear any of you nazis crying crocodile tears and shouting your ignorant, whiny, programmed responses at them. Or the fact that Jordan rescinded thousands of fakestinian passports, only to purposely use them as pawns against Israel. Israel is the only democracy in the middle east you clown, so your trite and downright stupid comparison of Israel to apartheid South Africa is as laughable as you are.
Check out Goldstone apologizing for his baseless report. Can't wait for the rest of you wanna be nazis to follow suit. Haha and americafirst, you really brought the point home with that 'lol'. Google: inquisition. Google: pogroms. Google: thousands of years of christian sponsored terrorism, anti-semitism, and murder. Aw they burned a few books and spit in the face of some jackass who was clearly enticing them, obviously that compares to your sordid and heinous past and present. Tisk tisk, never let facts get in the way of your stupidity, right?
Fun fact: over 80% of Americans support Israel, myself included.
Long live Israel. Am Yisrael Chai.
christwasawaywardJew
(04/03/11 6:52pm)Report
This comment has been removed by the Cavalier Daily staff for foul language, slurs, and offensive remarks about a religious community. The Cavalier Daily does not allow comments that disparage a particular racial, ethnic, or cultural group with foul language.
-The Online Editor
Sean
(04/04/11 1:16am)Report
But, naturally, the Cavalier Daily has no problem whatsoever with someone saying that another particular religion is "bursting at the seams with blood" and is responsible for teen suicides.
It's also AOK, apparently, to say that Palestinians do not exist at all !
jewblackmail
(04/05/11 11:38am)Report
funny that ONLY jews on campus support israel. pos
Sam
(04/05/11 2:27pm)Report
the above is definitely not true...