The Cavalier Daily
Serving the University Community Since 1890

Medical Center earns high marks

Several divisions of the University Health System received top-50 rankings in the U.S. News & World Report guide to best hospitals.

Its highest-ranking division, endocrinology and metabolism, was ranked sixth in the nation for its treatment of hormonal disorders.

The nephrology division was the University's highest-climbing division, moving up 12 slots to number 39.

Other University medical specialties ranked include: neurology (18th), cancer (19th), ear, nose and throat (20) and urology (21st).

U.S. News & World Report based rankings for 13 of the 17 specialties evaluated on a combination of factors, including reputation, mortality rates and American Hospital Association survey results.

The magazine determines a "reputational index" by sending questionnaires to 150 board-certified doctors in each specialty -- 2,500 in total -- asking them to choose the top five hospitals in their specialty, said Dr. Fabio Cominelli, chief of the division of gastroenterology (the study of stomach and intestinal disorders).

Dr. George F. Wooten of the neurology division said the subjective nature of the ranking methods make the magazine's lists somewhat questionable.

"The criteria [in the study] are subject to a lot of argument," Wooten said. The Health System was "probably hurt [in the rankings] by our relatively small population density and relatively small hospital."

Dr. Robert W. Cantrell, University vice president and provost for Health Sciences, said the Health System's consistently high rankings are proof of the quality of the staff here.

"Eleven out of 17 of our specialties were ranked, which is very good," Cantrell said. "Only 25 academic medical centers in the U.S. have that many ranked."

Related Links
  • UVa Health System News Release
  • US News & World Report's Best hospitals finder
  •  

    Cominelli said it is an honor for the University to receive such high rankings among all the other quality hospitals in the country.

    "For our division to be ranked 22nd is very significant. We are competing with places like the Mayo Clinic" in Rochester, Minn. Cominelli said.

    U.S. News & World Report's Web site states that to be eligible for these rankings, a hospital has to be "a member of the Council of Teaching Hospitals, to be affiliated with a medical school or to have at least nine out of 17 prescribed technological services."

    The print edition of the rankings hit newsstands July 17.

    Local Savings

    Puzzles
    Hoos Spelling

    Latest Podcast

    The Lorax Society is one of U.Va.'s many organizations with a focus on sustainability. The society’s mission is to preserve the natural biodiversity of Charlottesville. Maddie Foreman, the current president of the Lorax Society and second-year College student, discusses upcoming changes to the organization following the election of a new executive board, as well as her plans for new events and initiatives this semester.