Editor's note: The author of this article is over the age of 21.
Several weeks ago, I visited The Alley Light with my dear friend Lily. Wanting to make the most out of our last few weeks together — she was a second semester fourth-year at the time — we developed a wonderful tradition of exploring a new restaurant in Charlottesville every Thursday evening. We visited an array of eateries, such as C&O, Bar Tomas and The Bebedero, but while all these establishments were lovely, The Alley Light brought something uniquely memorable to the table.
Open Wednesday through Sunday from 5 p.m. to 10 p.m., The Alley Light is tucked into a small alley off of Second Street, and is anything but easy to spot. The restaurant itself hides behind a wooden barn door, and the only signage is a large, glowing lantern hanging above it, illuminating the otherwise onyx street. By design, The Alley Light isn’t just something you stumble upon — finding it is as deeply intentional as every single detail inside of the restaurant itself.
Inside, the space is intimate and antique, characterized by vintage artwork and beautiful old wood. I found it to be reminiscent of a speakeasy for both its obscured entrance and the way that old jazz music, emanating from a record player, floated through the subdued space.
Lily and I were promptly seated at a two-top in the middle of an open room, which was seemingly the only room in the restaurant. Our waiter later informed us that the space was a converted one-bedroom apartment — which explained both the fireplace and the deeply intimate ambiance.
We were warmly greeted by our waiter, who placed a seasonal cocktail menu in front of us. After perusing for a moment, I erroneously landed on the Taste the Rainbow, a cocktail made with Blanco Tequila, Ramazzotti Rosato, guava, grapefruit, lime and egg white — finished with glitter and amaro dust. Unsurprisingly, the drink was both fruit-forward and incredibly sweet. The titular Skittles reference was a very apt title for this cocktail, and while it was by no means bad, it faltered in comparison to Lily’s order.
Lily ordered the Unwed Sailor, The Alley Light’s inventive take on a bourbon sour. The drink is born from a blend of Elijah Craig, pecan orgeat, Pedro Ximénez, allspice, lemon and grapefruit. The charming coupe glass it came in was garnished with a piece of an orange peel cut into a parallelogram, fastened to the rim of the glass with an adorable miniature wooden clothespin.
The Unwed Sailor likely drinks like a rich, autumnal twist on a classic bourbon sour. The Elijah Craig bourbon provides a warm backbone of caramel, vanilla and oak, while the pecan orgeat adds a subtle nuttiness and creamy sweetness that softens the spirit's bite. Pedro Ximénez sherry, known for its intensely raisin-like, molasses-rich character, deepens the cocktail with notes of dried fruit, fig and toffee.
This cocktail was genuinely fantastic — it balances fresh lemon and grapefruit juice with notes of decadent caramel, toasted pecan and dried fruit. The hint of allspice added a wonderful wrinkle of spice, giving each sip a warm, spiced complexity beneath the cocktail’s refreshing citrus edge.
To be candid, I enjoyed this drink so much that, within a week, I had tracked down every obscure ingredient and started making it at home. In a strange way, it allowed me to bottle an evening I wasn't quite ready to let go of.
On the back of the cocktail menu listed some of their culinary offerings, neatly divided into five sections — small plates, terrines & rilettes, cured & tartares, gratinee and boards. Lily was generous enough to accommodate my gluten-free diet, which, after speaking to our waiter, struck most of the things on the menu off the list.
He then suggested we focus on their specials, listed on a chalkboard to our right, which placed a large emphasis on seasonal ingredients. Our eyes widened with excitement before they narrowed in deliberation.
After a long debate, Lily and I decided to order exclusively from the specials menu, and to split each dish down the middle — The Alley Light's recommended style of dining. We started with a simple salad, composed of an array of lettuces and fine herbs, tossed in a sherry vinaigrette. The lettuce was incredibly crisp and the herbs were beautifully fresh, all coated in a dressing that was bright and vinegar-forward. Ultimately, the dish was just lettuce, herbs and dressing, and while delicious, this simple salad was perhaps a bit too simple for its $10 price.
As a side, we ordered the spiced broccolini with lemon and garlic, which turned out to be the star of the show. The broccolini was perfectly cooked — it was tender yet snappy, sauteed in a blend of lemon, cayenne, paprika and garlic confit. The garlic confit added wonderful savory depth to the dish, playing a strong role in terms of flavor without overshadowing some of the more delicate undertones.
For our main courses, we landed on the seared scallops and the beef tenderloin. Although I am typically not a scallop fan, I was a bit nervous for Lilly’s suggestion of a seafood dish, but after demonstrating mastery with her drink order, I decided to trust her blindly. And I am so glad that I did.
This dish, described on the chalkboard as seared scallops with celery root, pickled blood orange and brown butter, delivered on every component of its ambitious description. The scallops were perfectly cooked — their tender centers were encased by a perfectly-seared, crusted outside. Not oceanic or briny — a gripe I often have with seafood — their tenderness melted in your mouth in tandem with the nutty, velvety brown butter.
Both the pickled blood orange and the celery root were served as purees, offering a diverse sauce-like accompaniment. While $39 is certainly on the steeper side of prices for five bivalves, I can confidently say that these were the best scallops I have ever had.
The second entree that arrived was the beef tenderloin, accompanied by duck fat potatoes, roasted baby romaine and anchovy. Served with understated elegance, two medium-rare filet-sized cuts of beef tenderloin sat atop a neatly-placed bed of lettuce and potatoes. The potatoes were fantastic — crispy outsides with a soft inside — although both Lily and I wished there were at least twice as many of them on the plate.
The meat itself was strikingly tender and perfectly cooked, if a little under. While the lack of sauce allowed the freshness of the beef to shine, we agreed that it was missing that additional fold of flavor into this large cut of steak. However, in terms of restaurant costs, $42 for two 4 ounce pieces of beef tenderloin is more moderately priced in comparison to some of their other offerings.
Soaking in the incredible meal we just devoured, Lily and I looked around and realized that there had been virtually no turnover throughout our 90 minutes of dining.
It was easy to see why — The Alley Light is the kind of place that invites guests to linger, and we happily relished in its warm, unhurried ambiance long after our plates had been cleared.
Although there are an infinite number of things I miss about my dinners with Lily, one of the things I miss the most is our shared belief in dessert. Although we were absolutely stuffed from our feast, the passionfruit cheesecake on the dessert menu beckoned us like moths to a flame.
The cheesecake arrived in a deconstructed fashion — a circle of buttery, compacted crust topped with a perfectly circular dollop of cheesecake. Running us $11, the cheesecake itself was rich, incredibly creamy and delightfully passionfruit-forward. It tasted like a citrus curd, but had the texture of a cheesecake, and its smooth texture made it impossible not to chase every last bite around the plate with a spoon — one that Lily and I agreed was the perfect shovel-like shape.
Although I didn’t know it at the time, The Alley Light was the final Thursday night dinner I would share with Lily. While both the Charlottesville restaurant scene and I will miss her presence immeasurably, I truly could not have imagined a better final chapter to this wonderful tradition. I do not have a sister, but I am fairly certain that Lily is as close as I will ever get.
So, as I sat down to write this article in Lily’s old room, which I have now moved into, I was struck by the realization that there would not be another Thursday night dinner — that I would have to experience the University without her infectious joy by my side. And in searching for solace, I stumbled upon former University President Jim Ryan’s 2025 Final Exercises speech, where he promised to each graduating student, “and should that road ever lead you back to Charlottesville, as I hope and trust it will, please know that we will leave the lights on for you.”
And because Lily has always had a knack for being one step ahead, it occurred to me — in a moment of complete serendipity — that The Alley Light had made that promise long before Ryan ever did.
Read More
McIntire students navigate finance recruiting between new and old programs
By Malaika Rehman | 5 days agoIn a process dominated by high-stakes competition, constant networking and intense technical preparation, students across both McIntire programs emphasized a common theme — while access to resources matters, initiative matters more.
An insider’s guide to eating on and around Grounds on a budget
By Ingrid Gay and Lily Notter | July 3, 2026Despite the high standards the University has set in nearly all aspects of undergraduate life, some find that dining options on Grounds fall short.
LGBTQ+ owned eateries you must try in Charlottesville
By Ingrid Gay | July 1, 2026As Pride Month wraps up, here are some of my top dining choices for your next meal out that are owned and operated by LGBTQ+ members of the Charlottesville community.
