To the Editor:
The Cavalier Daily was right to argue a lecturer's criticism of Black Lives Matter was protected by the First Amendment in its Oct. 10 editorial.
Doug Muir’s criticism of BLM as supposedly being racist was protected by the First Amendment, under court rulings like Dube v. State University of New York (1990). That ruling concluded a professor had a First Amendment right to repeatedly declare that Zionism is racism. His speech was protected even though it infuriated many.
Worse speech has been held protected. In Levin v. Harleston (1992), an appeals court ruled the First Amendment protected a professor whose published "writings contained a number of denigrating comments concerning the intelligence and social characteristics of blacks."
Sincerely,
Hans Bader
CLAS ‘91
Read More
HAWKINS: Virginia’s budget ‘compromise’ tries and fails
By Joshua Hawkins | 4 days agoAs families across our Commonwealth struggle to make ends meet, Virginians are yet again saddled with a state legislature with no concept of what the public actually wants.
KURTZWEIL: Keep Virginia’s energy Virginian
By Paul Kurtzweil | July 27, 2026This merger will only make Dominion and NextEra more powerful, but the benefits to taxpayers are slim.
EDITORIAL: The Board’s McKinsey retreat prioritizes corporatization over cooperation
By Editorial Board | July 22, 2026While some private meetings under certain circumstances may have benefits, McKinsey’s involvement flips the script in a dangerous way.
